Property tax rarely turns on the headline rules. Recent tribunal decisions show that the outcome often depends on the facts: how a property was owned, what was agreed, and how land was actually used. Below are five recent cases and the lessons they hold for landlords, families and trustees.
1. Rebuilding your home: relief follows the house, not the land
In HMRC v Lee (Upper Tribunal, 2023), a couple bought a plot, demolished the existing house and built a new home, which they lived in until they sold it. HMRC argued that private residence relief should be time-apportioned over the whole period they owned the land, which would have relieved only 18/43rds of the gain. Both the First-tier and Upper Tribunals disagreed. “Period of ownership” refers to ownership of the dwelling house, so the full gain qualified for relief.
2. Business property relief: being busy isn’t enough
In Butler (First-tier Tribunal, 2023), a family LLP ran a wedding venue from a converted barn on a farm. Although the business was active and growing, the Tribunal found it was mainly holding investments. Business property relief was refused, leaving around £1.67m of inheritance tax to pay. The question is what services are provided beyond letting the property, not how hard the owner works.
The stakes are also higher now. Since 6 April 2026, 100% business and agricultural property relief is capped at £2.5m per person, with 50% relief above that. Estates holding significant property or business assets should be reviewed.
3. Hybrid LLP structures: HMRC says they don’t work
In its Spotlight 63 guidance, HMRC warns against schemes where landlords move a property portfolio into an LLP with a corporate member. These schemes claim to get round the finance cost restriction, reduce capital gains tax and secure inheritance tax relief. HMRC’s view is that the arrangements fail under existing anti-avoidance rules. Anyone using them can expect a challenge, as well as interest and penalties.
4. Separation: the beneficial interest matters
In Wilmore (First-tier Tribunal, 2023), a separating couple’s verbal agreement over a jointly owned property created a constructive trust before the end of the tax year. That meant the transfer qualified for no gain/no loss treatment. Legal title isn’t the whole story: who is beneficially entitled can decide the outcome. Since April 2023, separating couples have up to three years after they stop living together to make no gain/no loss transfers.
5. SDLT and mixed-use land
In Brzezicki (First-tier Tribunal, 2024), part of a residential purchase included land used to breed trout for fly-fishing. The Tribunal held that this land was non-residential, so the lower mixed-use SDLT rates applied. It was a split decision, which shows how much these cases depend on their facts.
The basics people still get wrong
- The capital gains tax annual exempt amount is now £3,000.
- Gains on UK residential property must be reported and the tax paid within 60 days of completion.
- The final period of ownership that qualifies for private residence relief is generally nine months.
- The furnished holiday lettings regime was abolished from April 2025.
Our view
Record the facts as they happen. Intentions, agreements and how a property is actually used often decide the result, and they are much harder to prove years later.
If you own property personally, through a company or in trust, or are planning for inheritance tax, contact Aayan & Co Limited to arrange a consultation.
This article is general information, not advice. Please take advice specific to your circumstances before acting.